A South Carolina judge on Friday denied Alex Murdaugh's motion to dismiss the indictments accusing him of murdering his wife and son, keeping the case alive as he heads toward a retrial next year. Judge Debra McCaslin ruled that the defense had not shown any basis to throw out the charges.
The ruling matters now because Murdaugh is trying to undo the legal footing of a case that already sent him to prison before his 2023 murder convictions were overturned. His defense asked the court to toss the indictments on the theory that the grand jury process was tainted, but McCaslin said the record did not show intentional prosecutorial or investigative misconduct.
That challenge centered on testimony presented to the Colleton County grand jury by former State Law Enforcement Division agent David Owen. Defense attorney Jim Griffin argued that Owen misled jurors when he described blood spatter on Murdaugh's shirt and the way firearms on the property matched ammunition used to kill Paul Murdaugh. Griffin said the testimony was false and should not have supported the indictments.
McCaslin was not persuaded. In her ruling, she said the record did not show that any evidence was fabricated or that false testimony was knowingly presented to the grand jury. She also wrote that even if the disputed shirt and ammunition testimony were left out, the remaining unchallenged evidence still overwhelmingly established probable cause. That finding keeps the murder charges in place and removes the defense's most recent attempt to derail the case before trial.
Owen had testified that he told the grand jury an expert found multiple particles of blood spatter on Murdaugh's shirt, and he later said he had not seen a report finding no human blood on the shirt until after Murdaugh had been indicted. He also acknowledged that he inaccurately told jurors that other firearms at the Murdaugh property were loaded in a similar way to the shotgun used to kill Paul. Owen said, however, that he was not trying to trick grand jurors. Prosecutor Creighton Waters said the claims about the shirt were believed to be true at the time and that there was much more compelling evidence that would have gone before the grand jury, including video from Paul's cell phone that he said captured Paul, Maggie and Alex Murdaugh together just moments before the killings.
The case now moves toward a retrial that is set for next year, with the indictments intact and the defense left to fight the charges in open court rather than at the grand jury stage. Maggie Murdaugh was 52 and Paul Murdaugh was 22 when they were found dead from multiple gunshot wounds at the family's hunting estate in 2021, and Friday's ruling leaves that killing case exactly where the state wanted it to stay: on track for another trial.

