The full Fifth Circuit has ruled that the US House broke the Constitution when it passed a spending package by proxy voting during the Covid-19 pandemic, a decision that could ripple into challenges to laws enacted in the fiscal 2023 spending package. The en banc court in New Orleans said remote voting in the House violated the Quorum Clause and sent the fight toward the US Supreme Court.
The case now sits at the center of a question with immediate legal stakes: if proxy voting made one law unconstitutional, how many other provisions from that same spending package could be vulnerable too? That is why the ruling is drawing fresh attention now, especially because the package includes the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, the law Texas challenged in the case.
Judge Cory Wilson wrote that the Constitution’s “text, context, original understanding, and unbroken historical application” all show that Members of Congress must be physically present for quorum purposes. He said proxy presence does not count and that the Quorum Clause’s limits “cannot be circumvented by congressional fiat.”
The practical effect is harder to contain than the majority’s reasoning suggests. Wilson said the decision applies only to Texas’ challenge to a federal law requiring accommodations for pregnant employees, but Judge James Graves Jr. questioned how a ruling that the entire statute was passed unlawfully could be confined to one small sliver of a multi-trillion dollar bill. Graves said there was no explanation for limiting the judgment that way.
That split matters because other federal courts had rejected proxy-voting challenges when the rule was adopted, finding those cases barred by the Constitution’s Speech or Debate clause. At the time, only the House used proxy voting during the pandemic; senators kept voting in person. Conservative judges on the Fifth Circuit also expressed doubt during arguments in May, pressing the Justice Department on what attendance means if it is not physical presence in Congress.
US District Judge James Wes Hendrix ruled in favor of Texas in 2024, and a Fifth Circuit panel later said Congress acted within its authority when it created the proxy voting rule. The full court then took up the case and vacated that panel ruling. The latest decision now leaves Texas with a win and opens the door to new challenges over how much of the fiscal 2023 spending package can survive. An appeal to the US Supreme Court is the next step.

