Bonnie Blue is back to making the same claim she walked away from two months ago: she says she is pregnant. The former OnlyFans star, whose real name is Tia Billinger, said in May that she is expecting, reviving a story that has already gone through a public claim, a retreat and another claim.
Blue first said in February that she was pregnant weeks after having unprotected sex with 400 men as part of what she described as a breeding mission. In a YouTube video posted that month, she said she had been sick, had a headache she called a “mega migraine,” and felt certain foods were making her ill. She filmed an at-home pregnancy test on camera, then said an alleged ultrasound later confirmed it. “That is a pretty… it’s like half pink, half white. Kind of looks like a drumstick actually. Yeah, definitely pregnant. Like fully pregnant,” she said in the video. She added, “Oh, is that the baby?” and, when the result appeared to show a positive test, “That’s actually crazy.”
The claim carried weight because Blue had already told Us Weekly she had struggled with fertility in the past. She said she had tried for years to get pregnant with her ex-partner, that she “really, really struggled,” and that she would likely have to go down the IVF route. “So I wish I could say I might get pregnant, however, I’m not in that position where I can fall pregnant naturally,” she said. Blue separated from her estranged husband, Oliver Davidson, in 2023.
Then came the reversal. In March, Blue admitted the entire pregnancy had been a stunt. She later said she would like to auction off the baby’s name and wanted her fans involved in a gender reveal, turning the topic into part of the same performance that had already drawn fierce reaction online. “To the women showing anger towards me because they’ve experienced a miscarriage, that’s wrong,” she said. “It’s terrible that they’ve gone through such a loss and I genuinely can’t comprehend what they’ve had to endure. But I am not the reason for it.”
Blue also pushed back against criticism that her claims were mocking women who had miscarried. “It’s my body and I can choose to share news about my pregnancy however I wish,” she said, adding, “It does not mock miscarriages at all.” She told Us that “women’s bodies come in all different shapes and sizes” and that “it’s not my job to convince them I am actually pregnant.” When skeptics pointed to a video from her annual spring break event, in which she wore a bikini and a towel and appeared to have a silicone bump, the doubts only grew. Blue replied in a separate video filmed outside a villa in Mexico that she was carrying a doll around this year because she is pregnant: “So enjoy watching me carrying a doll around this year, because I am pregnant.”
That is why the latest claim in May matters now. Blue is not just repeating a pregnancy announcement; she is asking the public to believe her after she already said the earlier version was staged. On the record, she has said she could not conceive naturally, had considered IVF, and had spent years struggling to get pregnant. She has also said the more people doubt her, the more attention the story gets. “The more doubts, the more comments, the more views, and it will stay that way,” she said. For now, the question is not whether she has kept people talking. It is whether this new claim is a fresh fact or another turn in a story Blue herself has already shown she is willing to rewrite.
