Reading: James Gray says his Ad Astra cut gave Donald Sutherland more screen time

James Gray says his Ad Astra cut gave Donald Sutherland more screen time

Published
2 min read
Advertisement

James Gray says his version of Ad Astra was 12 minutes shorter than the theatrical cut, had far less narration and ended on a bleaker note that he says was closer to what he intended. In a recent Reddit AMA, the director described a cut that would restore more of Ruth Negga and Donald Sutherland, the latter having died in 2024.

Gray said the version he made ended with the lead being led out of the capsule, out of focus, and collapsing, rather than with the emotional landing on Earth that audiences saw in theaters. That difference matters because it changes the film from a story of hard-won closure into something much more severe and unresolved.

The director’s comments arrive with unusual specificity. He said his cut would use less narration, and that the changes were not minor trims but a different shape for the film itself. He also said the opening and closing used Wagner’s overture to Parsifal in his version, while the version released theatrically carried late-added narration and reshoots he did not sign off on.

- Advertisement -

That is the friction at the center of Ad Astra. The theatrical version gave McBride emotional closure on Earth, while Gray says his cut ended much earlier and far more bleakly. He has long maintained that the film was taken away from him, and he previously called the narration a choice that was not his.

Gray also pointed to the material around Negga and Sutherland as part of what would make the film “quite different” if restored. For now, though, the alternate version exists only in his description. The unanswered question is not what he thinks changed. It is whether that cut will ever be approved, or whether Ad Astra will remain split between the film Gray says he made and the one audiences actually saw.

Advertisement
Share This Article