Matthew Rhys says a joke he made during a 2006 Bond audition meeting may have cost him one of the most famous roles in film. He said the exchange with Daniel Craig’s 007 team went silent after he suggested James Bond should have a limp, then made it worse by adding: “Eye patch.”
Rhys said he was asked what he would do differently if he got the chance to play James Bond in Casino Royale, and he answered with what he later called a terrible joke. He said it was his Bond moment, but not in the way he wanted: the room went very quiet, and the awkward stretch lasted about 30 seconds before the meeting moved on.
The actor’s recollection has resurfaced at a moment when the next chapter of the franchise is already taking shape. Robert Pattinson was named the next actor to take on the James Bond role on Monday, while Denis Villeneuve is set to direct the new film for Amazon MGM Studios after the Broccoli family handed the franchise’s rights to Jeff Bezos-owned company last year. That puts Rhys’s story back into a casting process that has already moved from Craig’s first turn in Casino Royale to his final outing in No Time to Die in 2021.
Rhys said he was among a relatively large group of young white men invited to read for Casino Royale and go to the Broccoli family’s office, and he still does not have a coherent answer that would have wowed the producers that day. That is the sharpest part of his story: he does not only think the joke hurt his chances, he also says he cannot point to the perfect reply that would have saved him. He often wonders how Craig responded, which suggests the question was never just about one bad line but about whether he could make a case for his own version of Bond at all.
The wider Bond search has since kept moving. Nicholas Hoult, Josh O’Connor, Callum Turner and Jack Lowden reportedly took part in screen tests for the upcoming film, making Rhys’s failed audition feel less like an isolated mishap than one more missed turn in a long and closely watched casting race. For Rhys, though, the memory seems fixed on that brief silence in the room, when a joke about a limp and an eye patch turned into the moment he says he lost his shot.

