Gov. Kathy Hochul vetoed a bill on Friday that would have banned potassium bromate in New York, stopping a measure that also targeted FD&C Red 3 and propylparaben. The decision keeps the additives in place for now in products sold across New York State, from supermarket bread to bakery staples.
Hochul framed the move as a cost decision. In a statement, she said: “When it comes to New York's famous pizza and bagels, the only thing that should rise is the dough, not the cost.” She also said the bill’s goal was laudable, but its enactment would put New York businesses at a competitive disadvantage, force consumers to pay more for staple groceries and raise costs for taxpayers.
The timing matters because the bill had already passed the State Senate and Assembly in May, and the veto arrived on Friday after weeks of pressure from both food companies and local shop owners. The Consumer Brands Association lobbied against the measure, warning that it could push grocery prices higher and cost New York State more than $21 million in regulatory and information technology costs. That figure points to the kind of changes the bill would have forced inside state government: new reporting rules, new systems to track them and the staff time to run them.
For pizzerias, the fight was never just about a label on a package. Potassium bromate is used in the most common flour in Long Island pizzerias, where it strengthens dough and helps it rise higher. Rob Cervoni, who uses only unbleached, unbromated flour at Taglio Pizza in Mineola and Massapequa Park, said Friday he was not surprised by the veto. “It would have cost too much money. It's so much bigger than pizza and bagels; this would have affected all of the bread in the supermarket,” he said.
There was also a gap between the bill's health pitch and the costs it would have imposed. The measure would have required manufacturers to report the use of GRAS ingredients, which are generally recognized as safe by experts but not approved by the FDA. It also would have reached ingredients used beyond bread, including propylparaben, often found in tortillas, cookies, cakes and other baked goods to keep them fresh longer. Anthony Laurino, who owns Phil’s Pizzeria & Restaurant in Syosset and uses All Trumps flour, a bleached and bromated product widely used by cafeterias, bagel shops and industrial bakeries, said the impending decision did not worry him. “I had a feeling it wouldn't go through. I kept doing what I was doing and stayed out of the controversy. There are plenty of things that are bad for you and the government does nothing about it,” he said.
With the veto, New York will not be rewriting the ingredient rules for these products now. The question left is narrower and more practical: whether the state’s next fight over food additives will be about health claims, cost, or both at once.

