James P. Sullivan stumbled over a question about the 22nd Amendment on Wednesday and then refused to say whether Donald Trump could run for president a third time during his Senate nomination hearing. The Texas state Supreme Court justice said answering would violate Canon 5.
That exchange put a federal judicial nominee on the spot over one of the clearest rules in the U.S. Constitution: a person cannot be elected president more than twice. Sullivan, who was nominated by President Donald Trump to become a federal judge in Texas after losing his reelection bid earlier this month, first appeared to struggle when asked to explain the amendment before acknowledging its basic meaning.
Chris Coons pressed the point directly. He said the amendment and Trump’s own suggestions that he could run again could not both be true, then quoted the text of the rule: “The amendment is bracingly clear: ‘No person shall be elected to the office of the president more than twice,’” he said. Sullivan did not dispute the wording, but when Coons asked whether Trump could seek a third term, Sullivan declined to answer.
He tied that refusal to judicial ethics. Sullivan said that, as a nominee for a federal district court, giving an opinion on the question would be a violation of Canon 5, the ABA rule that bars judicial candidates from making statements that would commit them on cases, controversies or issues likely to come before the court. He also said the issue seemed like the kind of subject that belongs in ongoing political debate.
The friction in the hearing was not over whether the 22nd Amendment exists or what it says. It was over whether a nominee can use Canon 5 to avoid answering a constitutional question that is already part of the political fight around Trump. Sullivan’s answer left the issue unresolved in the only way that matters for his nomination: he would not say where he stands, even when asked straight out.
That refusal may protect him before the hearing, but it also leaves his confirmation path clouded. Sullivan had served just under two years on Texas’s high court after a vacancy opened, and he had been appointed by Greg Abbott in early 2025 after years as the governor’s general counsel. Now the question is whether the Senate treats his silence as caution or as a reason to dig deeper before advancing him.

