Reading: Finn Wittrock leads Thanksgiving biopic Hershey in sanitized rise-to-fame story

Finn Wittrock leads Thanksgiving biopic Hershey in sanitized rise-to-fame story

Published
3 min read
Advertisement

The Hollywood Reporter has reviewed Hershey, a Thanksgiving-release biopic that puts Finn Wittrock in the title role as Milton Hershey. Mark Waters directs the 1 hour 50 minute film, which arrives as a PG, studio-style account of how the candy maker rose to prominence.

That is the reason the movie is drawing notice now: it is not just another period drama, but a holiday release built around one of the most familiar American brand names. Wittrock carries the story through Milton’s climb, with Alexandra Daddario, Alan Ruck and Richard Kind among the co-stars, while Hershey Entities helped produce it and Angel Studios handled distribution. For viewers searching for what the film actually covers, the answer is simple enough at first glance: the arc runs from a young boy in 1870 in a Mennonite community in rural Pennsylvania to the man who turns a failed caramel business into a chocolate empire.

James Kelly plays that younger Milton in the opening stretch, after the death of his sister and the abandonment of the family by his father send him to work for Joseph Royer. From there the film moves through a failed caramel shop, then a store in Lancaster that takes off after a bulk order from a visiting Englishman, before Hershey pivots to chocolate and declares that caramel is a fad while chocolate is permanent. A salesman for a German chocolate company warns him that he is missing what is next, and that line becomes the hinge for the rest of the story.

- Advertisement -

The problem is what the film leaves out while polishing everything else. The review describes Hershey as blandly sanitized, as sweet as the candies the company sells, and that sweetness has a cost: violent labor disputes in later years are not part of the film, and neither is the fact that the school for impoverished youth was restricted to whites. Black students were not admitted until 1968. The movie does show Hershey opening that school at the urging of his wife, and it shows him turning the village where he grew up into the company town that still bears his name, but the rougher history stays offscreen.

So the film lands less as a full account of Milton Hershey than as a curated version of him, one that favors uplift over contradiction. Finn Wittrock’s performance is the center of that strategy, but the unanswered question is not whether Hershey sells the rise — it does — it is how much of the man’s legacy the movie is willing to leave outside the frame.

Advertisement
Share This Article