The Hey Arnold mission in Grand Theft Auto VI ends with Jason at the dock, staring at Arnold after a chase that has already turned into a crash and a foot pursuit. At that point, the game gives him the choice that players are searching for now: spare Arnold or kill him.
That choice sits at the center of Chapter 1 because it is the only clear branch in the mission’s ending. Jason starts it by meeting Brian at a hotel marked on the map, then drives Brian’s pickup truck with Cal along for the confrontation that pushes Arnold to run. By the time Jason catches him at the end of the dock, the mission has moved from a straightforward chase to a decision that changes how the scene closes.
The mechanics are simple. Arnold drives off after the confrontation, Jason chases him in the truck, and the player can shoot while driving with R1 or RB. Arnold eventually crashes and runs on foot before Jason reaches him at the dock, where he kneels and waits for the final input. If Jason spares him, Arnold swims away. If he is killed, the chase ends there. That makes the moment feel like more than a flourish; it is the payoff for the mission’s entire setup.
What the mission does not spell out is just as important as what it does. The choice is explicit, but there is no clear explanation here of whether sparing Arnold changes a later mission, unlocks a reward, or alters the story in any lasting way. For a walkthrough, that missing piece matters because it leaves the decision looking meaningful without showing how far that meaning carries.
That uncertainty is why the next step in the chapter matters. After the mission, Brian introduces Jason to Kenton at a pool gathering, and the story moves on from the dock without showing a visible punishment or payoff for either outcome. In practice, the answer to should I spare Arnold in GTA 6 is narrower than it first appears: the choice changes the scene in front of Jason, but the available facts stop short of proving that it changes the chapter beyond that.
For now, the safest reading is that the dock choice is a branching ending, not a confirmed story fork. Jason can let Arnold swim away or end it there, but the mission still closes with Brian moving him toward Kenton and the next stretch of Chapter 1.

