Reading: Elissa Slotkin tells Aaron Reitz to withdraw investigation threat over speech

Elissa Slotkin tells Aaron Reitz to withdraw investigation threat over speech

Published
3 min read
Advertisement

Sen. Elissa Slotkin fired back on Wednesday at Aaron Reitz, telling the Justice Department official to withdraw what she called a baseless threat to investigate her political speech. The Michigan Democrat said his move crossed a line by turning protected remarks into the target of a public inquiry.

Slotkin said she made the comments at issue under her basic right to freedom of speech and that the Constitution’s Speech or Debate clause bars prosecution of a lawmaker for conducting an investigation or carrying out other legislative acts. She wrote that Reitz’s public threats violated Justice Department policy and that his decision to post the letters online showed the matter was more about publicity and political ambition than any legitimate inquiry.

The dispute lands in the middle of an escalating fight over whether elected officials can be singled out for comments made in the course of oversight work. Reitz, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Texas, had posted letters on social media to five Democratic members of Congress, including Slotkin, Elizabeth Warren, Richard Blumenthal, Robert Garcia and Adam Schiff. One of those letters suggested that Slotkin’s comments about congressional oversight could amount to a criminal civil rights offense.

- Advertisement -

Reitz told News that he was not interested in chilling free speech. Slotkin’s letter drew a hard line anyway: she said his threat should be withdrawn immediately, and she treated the public posting itself as evidence that the effort was designed to make a political point rather than build a case.

The friction is sharper because this is not the first time Slotkin and other Democrats have been pulled into a legal fight over speech. Earlier this year, Slotkin and five other sitting Democratic lawmakers were targeted over a social media video about unlawful orders, and allies of the U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia, Jeanine Pirro, tried to indict the six Democrats for that speech. Federal grand jurors unanimously rejected the effort. Slotkin’s attorney, Prett Bharara, later warned Attorney General Todd Blanche against following Donald Trump’s public instruction to look into Slotkin’s political speech, and Blanche responded last week that her words alone were “absolutely not a crime” and that there were no ongoing criminal investigations into words said by incoming senators or congressmen.

Reitz, who once served as chief of staff for Ted Cruz and became U.S. attorney over the summer after placing fourth in the Republican primary for Texas attorney general, has now put himself at the center of a fight over where oversight ends and prosecution begins. Whether he follows Slotkin’s demand or keeps pressing the inquiry is the question that will decide whether this remains a public warning or becomes an actual case.

Advertisement
Share This Article