Reading: David Smith will oppose Susan Smith’s parole at hearing on November 19

David Smith will oppose Susan Smith’s parole at hearing on November 19

Published
3 min read
Advertisement

David Smith will go back before the parole board on Thursday, November 19, and ask it to keep Susan Smith in prison. He and his wife, Tiffany Smith, plan to attend the hearing and urge the board to deny her release, setting up another bitter moment in a case that has already followed the family for more than three decades.

It is the second time Smith has had to face a parole hearing after being sentenced to life in prison in 1995 for rolling her car into South Carolina's John D. Long Lake with Michael and Alex strapped inside. Michael was 3 and Alex was 14 months old when they were killed in 1994, after Smith first claimed a man had carjacked her and taken the boys.

The first hearing came in 2024, when the board unanimously denied her release after emotional pleas from David Smith, Tiffany Smith and their daughter, Savannah. This time, David Smith said he is not looking forward to speaking again, but plans to be there every time. He said he wants the board to keep her incarcerated because of what she did to Michael and Alex, not because of what was done to him.

- Advertisement -

That distinction has been central to his view of the case. David Smith said not a day goes by without him thinking of his sons, and he said he made peace with the tragedy years ago. But he also said he does not believe Susan Smith is remorseful, pointing to what he sees as her behavior over the years in prison. He said that in their last direct conversation, about a month after her confession, she told him, “I’m sorry. I don’t know why I did it,” during about an hour he was allowed to speak with her.

The hearing also comes with a record that has only hardened the opposition around her release. Susan Smith has been disciplined in prison for numerous violations ranging from drug offences to sexual relations with prison staff. Tiffany Smith said she thinks Susan Smith should not be eligible to appeal for parole at all, and said she is appalled at her lack of accountability over the past 30 years. In her view, the life sentence should mean life, especially after two children were taken and never given another chance.

Smith became nationally known after she appeared on TV with David Smith and made a plea for the children to be returned safely before confessing nine days later. The board will now hear the case again with that history in the room, along with the memory of the first denial in 2024. What happens next is straightforward: the parole board will decide whether Susan Smith remains behind bars for life, or whether the fight over her sentence enters another round.

Advertisement
Share This Article