McCall DaPron says she texted Mayci Neeley after a heated Palm Springs dinner confrontation because she felt alone and wanted her sister on her side. The message, sent after McCall went toe-to-toe with Avery Woods and Bobbi Althoff, pulled family into the middle of the first season’s cast drama on Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County.
That is why the exchange is getting attention now. McCall is a star of the series, and she says the text did not come out of nowhere — she and Mayci were already messaging when the dispute spilled over. She said she was talking to her sister about the girls being upset over the video Mayci posted around the time the show was announced, which is the clip that helped frame the conflict before the dinner scene even played out.
Mayci’s video mattered because it was not a direct name-check, but it still landed as a shot across the group. In it, she said certain cast members were only there for clout and threw shade at the less-religious women without naming anyone. McCall says that set the tone for the argument in Palm Springs, where she was pressed on the difference between what she meant and how her actions were read by the others.
McCall said she did not see the text as anything dramatic at the time. What made it explode was Mayci’s response to hearing that her sister was crying. “When I told her I was crying, that’s when she freaked out because I honestly don’t cry very often,” McCall said, adding that she felt grateful to have a sister who had her back 100 percent when, as she put it, no one else seemed to be there for her.
That is the friction running through the whole story: McCall says she was reaching out from a place of hurt, but Mayci’s defense of her ended up making the situation worse overall. McCall also says she is still learning how to move through a group setting like this one, where friends, family and castmates overlap in ways that can turn a private message into part of the show’s public conflict.
She said her background helps explain why the group dynamic has been difficult. Growing up in California, she said, hardly any of her friends were LDS, and most of the people she knows now are not members either. That is part of why she says she did not feel judgmental coming in, even if some of the women assumed her traditional values meant she would judge them.
Mayci later appeared alongside Mikayla Matthews during a Las Vegas trip, showing the group was still moving forward even after the dinner fight and the messages that followed. But the central question remains the one McCall’s account leaves hanging: whether a sisterly defense can calm a cast feud, or whether it only gives the argument a new place to spread.

