Fayetteville State will open the NCAA Division II Atlantic Region Tournament against Shepherd on November 20, 2026, with a 7:00 PM first-round match at Highmark Events Center in Erie, PA. The Broncos are the No. 5 seed; Shepherd is No. 4.
The matchup is drawing attention because Fayetteville State enters at 25-4 after winning its second consecutive CIAA Volleyball Championship, while Shepherd arrives with a 23-4 record and a 12-2 conference mark. Kemyah Harris leads the Broncos with 293 kills, and that production helped carry a team averaging 12.6 kills per set while holding opponents to a.102 hitting percentage.
That is the kind of balance that makes Fayetteville State hard to dismiss, but Shepherd brings its own edge. The Rams are hitting.278 as a team and average 13.0 kills per set, a slight statistical advantage in the category most people notice first. On paper, the first-round game is close enough that seeding may matter as much as any single number.
Fayetteville State’s offense is spread across several threats. Mya Hejl has 226 kills, McKenna Miller has 196, and Kyla Powell has 176, while Giovanna Teixeira has 508 assists and Melissa Gonzalez has 438. Jasmine Culp anchors the back row with 361 digs and 40 service aces, and Hejl also leads the Broncos with 77 total blocks.
Shepherd has a similar depth chart built around different names. Ada McCoy has 270 kills, Amya Davis has 228, Sophia Ryan has 190, and Emily Ryder has 180. Maggie Smith has 818 assists, 30 service aces and 156 digs, while Alexa Smith has 348 digs, giving Shepherd a passing and setting core that has kept its numbers steady through the season.
What makes this matchup more than a seeding exercise is the contrast in how the two teams won their way here. Fayetteville State is coming off a conference title run and a dominant defensive profile, while Shepherd’s stronger hitting percentage suggests a team that can force the tempo if it gets into rhythm early. In a single-elimination opener, that leaves little margin for a slow start.
The next step is simple and unforgiving: the winner advances, and the loser goes home after one night in Erie. For Fayetteville State, the question is whether a championship-tested roster can turn its conference momentum into an NCAA Tournament win; for Shepherd, it is whether efficient offense can break through a team that has spent the season making opponents work for every point.

