Will Cuylle’s slump has reached the point where it is changing how the New York Rangers think about his next contract. Through the quarter mark of the season, he has four goals, five assists and nine points in 21 games, but that line looks less steady when split into a sharp opening and a quieter stretch.
That split matters because Cuylle is one of a few Rangers who will need a new deal after this season, and the timing leaves little room for drift. CapWages has projected him at $6,542,140 on a four-year contract, a structure that would carry him to age 29 and eat two UFA years, so the team has to decide whether his current production justifies that kind of commitment now.
The early numbers were strong enough to make the conversation straightforward at first. In his first 10 games, Cuylle scored three goals and added three assists for six points. Over his last 11, though, he has one goal, two assists and three points. For a player who is trying to turn a good start into contract leverage, that kind of drop changes the math quickly.
His track record also gives the Rangers something to weigh on both sides of the ledger. Last season, Cuylle went 1-3-4 in 12 October games, then 6-5-11 in 15 November games and 3-5-8 in 15 December games. In January, February and March, he appeared in 33 games and had six goals and four assists for 10 points, which shows he has already been through stretches where his scoring came and went in chunks.
That is the friction in the negotiations: the player who started fast is the same one who has now cooled off long enough to make the estimate less secure. If Cuylle steadies his scoring, the Rangers can treat the projection as a starting point. If he does not, the gap between a four-year contract on that number and a shorter, more cautious offer only gets wider.

