An insider has now claimed that Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield will keep showing up in Marvel projects after Avengers: Secret Wars, saying their Spider-Man stories will not end with that film and that plans already exist for two more appearances. The report lands as fan interest in Garfield’s future keeps building around the last stretch of the Multiverse Saga.
Garfield himself has not fed the speculation. He has denied being involved in Spider-Man: Brand New Day and Avengers: Doomsday, saying, "No, unequivocally f—ing no." But he has also left just enough room for debate, telling MTV, "See, what it is, is this a tell? Or what is it? You’ll find out!" That combination has kept every new claim about his Spider-Man future in circulation.
The latest post on X comes from MyTimeToShineHello, an insider account that has repeatedly pushed Spider-Man claims around Marvel Studios. Earlier, it said Garfield’s Spider-Man would get to fight an alien in Avengers Secret Wars and that Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield would both return in that film, though separated. The new claim goes one step further: the two actors are said to appear in two more projects beyond Avengers: Secret Wars.
That detail matters because it points to a longer runway than many fans expected. Avengers: Secret Wars is due on December 17, 2027, and it has already been treated as a major endpoint for the current Marvel stretch. If the claim is right, then the Spider-Man versions played by Maguire and Garfield would not be wrapping up there. They would be moving into at least two additional projects after that, which changes how the next phase of Marvel storytelling could be read.
Still, the report remains just that: a report. Marvel Studios has not confirmed the two extra projects, and the insider has not named them. That leaves the central question unresolved, even as the rumor gets repeated: whether the next appearances would be tied to the wider MCU, to Spider-Man: Brand New Day and Avengers: Doomsday, or to something else entirely. For now, Garfield’s own comments suggest he is not ready to confirm anything, even while he keeps fans guessing enough that, as he joked on Heart Radio, people may still be asking him about Spider-Man when he is 90.
For readers tracking the Marvel calendar, the immediate markers are clear. Spider-Man: Brand New Day arrives on July 31, Avengers: Doomsday opens on December 18, and Avengers: Secret Wars follows on December 17, 2027. The new insider claim does not settle Garfield’s future. It does something more useful for the moment: it pushes the conversation past Secret Wars and into what Marvel may have waiting after it.
