Kristin Cavallari says a second date that started like a dream ended with a man exposing himself to her at the Beverly Hills Hotel. On the latest episode of her Let’s Be Honest podcast, she said the encounter came after two dates she still describes as among the best of her life.

Cavallari said she went out with the unnamed man roughly four years ago, first at the Sunset Tower Hotel and then at the Beverly Hills Hotel. The first two dates, she said, were “two really great dates, honestly two of the best dates of my life,” and the second one turned into a long day in a suite, swimming, separate showers and dinner on the patio.

That night is where the story changed. Cavallari said the man asked if he could show her a mole on his penis, then pulled it out for her to see. She said she told him, “Put it away, f–king weirdo.”

She also said she had assumed the man was known for having a large penis, but that it was not especially big, and she tied that to what she saw as his insecurity. In the same recollection, she said he had “the flattest ass” and “horrible bacne scars” when he changed out of his swimsuit, a blunt detail that made the story sound less like a glamorous celebrity hookup than an awkward misfire.

Cavallari, a reality star turned podcaster and sometimes bikini model, did not name him, and she did not offer any follow-up that would identify the man later. For now, the revelation stands as a celebrity dating story with the central question left open: who was the very famous man she says exposed himself to her at the Beverly Hills Hotel?